Mixed Feelings about My Fence Replacement

It was very challenging finding a contractor and then actually getting the job finished

Submitted by Kelly B.


New cedar fence adjacent to my house

When I bought my house in December, it was a disaster. The previous owners had never touched the landscaping or the lawn. Now I’m just taking it one bite at a time. But the cedar fence was so rotten that it was literally falling down, so I had to take care of that. That was my big hoorah.

I’ll be honest with you, it was very challenging finding a contractor. I tried everything you can think of ... I did craigslist, I did referrals, I did Nextdoor, I did Facebook. Then I went online and contacted Networx and other referral agencies. Several contractors came out to look at the fence … and never came back.

Niche for my garbage bin

On the phone, most companies asked, “Well, how much can you spend?” My reaction to that was, “No, no, no, no!” It was really tough. People tell me that that’s pretty normal, which surprised me. I was finally able to find 5 Star Cedar Fences through Networx.

I actually got two and a half quotes altogether. What I call the half quote was just handwritten on paper -- not very professional. However, I’m glad I got what I got, and glad I don’t have to do it again for a very long time.

Concrete parking pad

The installer ripped down the old fence and replaced it with a new one, using materials he picked up at Home Depot. He also put a big concrete pad out there that I can park on, with a rolling gate. The job took a while to complete – about 2 weeks. It was originally supposed to be a 3-5 day job but the installer was a lone guy who would disappear for hours and then come back.

At the end, the whole thing got really shaky. They didn’t do some of the things they said they were going to do. I’m a project manager, so I had to manage them in finishing it. My original contact person apparently just handles phone calls and lives out in California, not in Denver where I had the work done. I would call him up and say, “Dude, they didn’t grade, they didn’t do this, they didn’t do that …”

Fence gate detail

And then I had to pay the installer cash. I was okay with that, except for the fact that I had to pay the installer in instalments when he showed up. Often he would say he’d be here at 9:00 and then wouldn’t show up till 2:00.

I hand wrote receipts out to the installer. My mom’s an attorney, so she said, “Every time you make a payment, write a receipt and have him sign it.” He would sign the paper and never ask me for his copy. It was just bizarre. The installer said it was $4,750 for the whole job. Then my mom and I had to break it down into payments because he couldn’t get the math right. It was a mess!

Cedar fence installation

After it was (finally!) done, the contact said, “I hope you’ll refer us out.” I replied, “Why? You didn’t do anything! I managed the whole thing!” The fence is gorgeous and I don’t have any issue with the work itself. I’m really glad it’s over, though, and I wouldn’t use that company or Victor (the installer) again. Networx was nice, but otherwise it was a painful process for me.

As my first and only experience with a contractor, I found it very challenging. If I were giving advice to a new homeowner about hiring a contractor, my first impulse would be to say, “For heaven’s sake, don’t do it!!” I would recommend getting a fixed bid and a fixed timeline in writing a written bid, and professional receipts as well.

 Parked on the concrete pad

Contractors in Your Local Area
It's Easy, Fast and Free!
Find Trusted Pros
5 Star Cedar Fences and Installations Kelly Bodnar: The work is spectacular. I had some issues with punctuality and timing. I ...

Have a great home-improvement experience?
We'd love to hear about it!



Contractors in Your Local Area
It's Easy, Fast and Free!
Find Trusted Pros

5 Star Cedar Fences and Installations Kelly Bodnar: The work is spectacular. I had some issues with punctuality and timing. I ...
The Best Contractor: Prompt, Accurate And Ready For The Unexpected by Nancy R.
How I Chose My Flooring Contractor And Why I’m Glad I Did by Natasha C.
Attic Stairs Install – High Quality, Reliable Service, Good Price by Pat K.
Have a great home-improvement experience?
We'd love to hear about it!